With countless new products available in
the market, many times you are confused about making the right
choice. This includes choices on drinking water. So many types
of drinking water with different processes and salesmen tricks
can only make it more overwhelming. Below is some information
to help you choose the right drinking water for you.
Reverse Osmosis (R.O.)
Reverse osmosis refers to a process of water purification
that has been used primarily for the desalination of seawater.
It involves applying pressure to reverse the natural flow
of water, forcing the water to move from the more concentrated
solution to the weaker. The semi-permeable membrane is porous,
allowing water to pass through, but blocking the passage of
the bulkier salt molecules. The end result is water sans salt
on one side of the membrane.
Reverse osmosis is effective at desalinating water and providing
mineral-free water for use in photo or print shops. It is
also effective at providing pathogen-free water. Still, even
though the small pores in the membrane block particles of
large molecular structure like salt, more dangerous chemicals
like pesticides, herbicides, and chlorine are molecularly
smaller than water. These chemicals can freely pass through
the porous membrane.
Another downside to reverse osmosis as a method of purifying
drinking water is the removal of healthy, naturally occurring
minerals in water. The membrane of a reverse osmosis system
is impermeable to natural trace minerals. These minerals not
only provide a good taste to water, but they also serve a
vital function in the body’s system. Water, when stripped
of these trace minerals, can actually be unhealthy for the
body.
Distillation
The distillation process utilizes a heat source to
vaporize water. The object of distillation is to separate
pure water molecules from contaminants with a higher boiling
point than water. Distillation, similarly to reverse osmosis,
provides mineral-free water to be used in science laboratories
or for printing purposes, as both functions require mineral-free
water. It removes heavy metal materials like lead, arsenic,
and mercury from water and hardening agents like calcium and
phosphorous.
Although distillation processes remove mineral and bacterial
drinking water contaminants, they do not remove chlorine,
chlorine byproducts, or VOCs. These chemicals, which have
a lower boiling point than water, are the major contaminants
of municipally treated water.
Distillation, like reverse osmosis, provides mineral-free
water that can be quite dangerous to the body’s system
when ingested, due to its acidity. Acidic drinking water strips
bones and teeth of valuable and essential mineral constituents.
About water refill station
Usually water refill station uses distillation or R.O. process
to take out all the healthy minerals that can benefit your
body. Even worse, some refill stations use tap water as their
so-called “cheap healthy water.” Please pay more
attention to your health.
Drinkable Oxygen?
Super oxygenated waters boast up to ten times more O2 content
than normal tap water. And more is better, right? Advertisements
say the body absorbs the extra O2, resulting in improved stamina
and athletic performance, reduced recovery time, and better
mental clarity. So ACE enlisted the Human Performance Research
Lab at the University of Wisconsin, La Crosse to test those
claims and compare the physical performance effects of super
oxygenated water.
The Study
Led by John Porcari, Ph.D., the research team recruited
12 healthy, college-aged women and men to participate in the
study. Separated into two groups of six, subjects were randomly
assigned to drink either 16 ounces of super oxygenated water
or regular tap water. After drinking the assigned type of
water, subjects sat quietly in a chair for five minutes while
researchers measured heart rate, blood pressure, blood lactate
and oxygen consumption. Next, each subject performed a multi-stage
VoO2max test on a treadmill. At the end of each stage (and
at maximal exertion), heart rate, blood pressure, ratings
of perceived exertion (RPE) and oxygen consumption (VoO2)
were recorded. Blood lactate was also measured at key times
throughout the test. One week later, subjects returned to
the laboratory and completed the same protocol using the opposite
condition (i.e., drinking the other type of water).
The Results
Researchers found that drinking super oxygenated
water had no measurable effect on the subjects' resting heart
rate, blood pressure or blood lactate values. Similarly, there
was no effect on heart rate, blood pressure or blood lactate
values during either the sub-maximal or maximal exercise tests.
A second maximal test was conducted immediately following
the first test to investigate the effects of super oxygenated
water on exercise recovery. If additional oxygen had, in fact,
been absorbed in the blood stream and delivered to the tissues,
there should have been measurable reductions in sub-maximal
exercise heart rates and blood lactate values, and increases
in maximal oxygen consumption during the second test. Apparently,
the blood oxygenation levels were either not elevated at all
or not elevated sufficiently to affect oxygen delivery to
the tissues or tissue metabolism.
The bottom line
At this time, there is no scientific evidence or
logical rationale to suggest that drinking super oxygenated
water can in any way increase the amount of oxygen in the
blood stream. Therefore, any potential benefits of super oxygenated
water would undoubtedly be attributed to the placebo effect.
"The bottom line is that this stuff is no more beneficial
than regular tap water," says lead researcher John Porcari,
Ph.D. "The physiological mechanism is not there to get
any potential benefit from the extra oxygen. There's just
no physical way this product can improve blood oxygenation."
Porcari says the results of the study were not a surprise
to the researchers. There are only two possible ways to carry
oxygen in the blood: Oxygen is either bound to hemoglobin
or dissolved in the plasma. "In normal healthy exercisers,
hemoglobin is already 97 to 98 percent saturated with oxygen,"
explains Porcari. "Obviously, there is very little room
to improve upon this factor." And the only known way
to increase the amount of oxygen dissolved in the blood is
to increase the partial pressure of oxygen in the lungs by
breathing either hyperoxic (higher percentages of oxygen)
or hyperbaric (greater pressure than found within the body)
oxygen mixtures during exercise. Both techniques have shown
increases of dissolved oxygen in the plasma and have resulted
in lower exercise heart rates, lower blood lactate values
and higher maximal oxygen consumption values. However, this
technique is only valuable during exercise and not beneficial
if done pre-exercise or during recovery.
In addition, Porcari notes that the super oxygenated water
must first be ingested and absorbed in the gut. Even if the
oxygen is absorbed, he explained, it would have to be absorbed
into venous blood. As soon as it passes through the lungs
for the first time, the blood would either release the oxygen
at the alveolar membrane or, more likely, not pick up as much
additional oxygen.
Although the researchers studied and analyzed only two different
brands of water, Porcari is confident all of the super oxygenated
waters on the market would provide similar results. "I
don't think it makes much difference how much oxygen the water
contains," says Porcari. "They could pump a thousand
milliliters of oxygen into the water but there's still no
physiologic mechanism to get that oxygen in the blood stream
where it can be used."
top ▲
|